Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Black Hole: Come, let us stroll arm in arm toward the event horizon


Oh hey, guys . . . do you wanna read a graphic novel that's an extended metaphor for "the nature of high school alienation itselfthe savagery, the cruelty, the relentless anxiety and ennui, the longing for escape"?


Yeah, I didn't either. But then I saw the part about how the high school students in this '70s suburban Seattle neighborhood are passing around an STD that manifests in different physical mutations (lizard tails that fall off and grow back later! tiny neck-mouths that wheeze in the night!). I can't resist a good wheezing neck-mouth.

In the appropriately titled Black Hole, we see the story from the perspectives of a few different characters, infected and noninfected and soon-to-be infected alike. In a lot of ways, it’s a typical slice of high school life. You have the popular kids and the rejects, same as always. The virus is just a way of making the politics of popularity more visible than usual. And it doesn’t matter if you were the prettiest, nicest girl in school before you got the plague; once everyone finds out that you slept with the neck-mouth guy and now your skin peels off in one big piece, you might rather drop out of school and live in the woods than face the inevitable social castigation.

But, just like high school, the cruelty doesn't necessarily stop even if you remove yourself from polite society and refuse to participate in teenage politics . . . because you can be judged less worthy and persecuted (and possibly beaten with a large stick) by your fellow freaks, too.

Hurray, high school!
So you might be wondering if I actually liked this graphic novel, and I certainly wish I could tell you. I can say that I didn't enjoy it. But that means nothing because I don't think it's meant to be enjoyed, per se. Even though the illustrations are in simple black and white, they still manage to be pretty cringe-inducing. And everything feels like the '70s, which is to say . . . kind of dirty? And then you have the generally unpleasant subject matter.

But the message is universal, and any time a story can connect with the shared experience of a whole age group, across generations, that's invaluable. I'm still trying to decide whether this would be a good book to put in the hands of kids who are currently in high school, or whether it's safer to consume it with the benefit of hindsight and stabilized hormone levels.

If any of you high schoolers out there do decide to pick this up, I would counsel you to remember that the book's reality is likely bleaker than your own, even if it doesn't always feel that way. For instance, do you have a tail that prevents you from wearing skirts? *waits while you double-check* I didn't think so. Also remember this:

Eventually, most awkward teenagers...

grow up.

20 comments:

  1. Mmmm Lee Pace.

    I'm sorry, what was that? There was some book you read? I got distracted.

    This sounds super creepy. Mostly the peel your skin off in one big piece, which skeevs me out more than lizard tails and wheezing neck-mouths. So I have learned something about myself. I am trying to try more graphic novels so I might tentatively put this on that TBR list. Cos I'm sort of afraid to try it with all the bleakness and '70s general stickiness that is the decade.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really stretched to figure out a way to include that GIF, because I wanted to look at it for a while.


    Doooon't begin your graphic novel career with this one. I know you already read FUN HOME, which was smart. You should...read some other ones before BLACK HOLE. Maybe BLANKETS? Less stickiness.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well wait. Because I feel like if I was DEFINITELY going to grow a neckmouth if I had sex with someone, I'd say no. People take a chance with pregnancy/whatever because it's not for sure. So is it like "Oh you MIGHT get a neckmouth," or is it for definite that you will.


    Also the '70s were gross. Obviously.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh you for sure know you're getting SOME kind of mutation. It's not a given how the virus will manifest physically, but if you sleep with someone who has it, you're doomed. Dooooooomed I say.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Did I bully you already about seeing CEREMONY, the movie from whence that GIF comes? It might've been Laura. I bully a lot of people to see that movie. He's Australian in it, Kayleigh! And maybe that doesn't impress you as much as it impresses me, but the accent is VERY attractive on him, as so many things are...including elf ears.


    Tell Tom that he's very nice just the way he is, but if he truly enjoyed reading Black Hole he may need a hug.

    ReplyDelete
  6. NO!Australian you say, hopefully it's good enough that I don't get distracted from his eyebrows. Ha, yeah actually even if he sounded like Tarantino in Django Unchained I'd still find him ridiculously attractive.

    ReplyDelete
  7. OK so I'm an idiot. He's BRITISH in Ceremony. But you should really see it. It's an all-around fantastic movie. And here's a present:
    http://youtu.be/J-hP8jVt7Qo

    ReplyDelete
  8. You are a most wonderful person Meg.

    ReplyDelete
  9. My motives are a little self-serving...and I watched that clip twice before I shared it with you.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Weird collection of ages in the cast though, are they meant to be the same/similar ages? Michael Angarano is my age and Uma Thurman must be at least 15 years older than him. Not that that will stop me from watching asap

    ReplyDelete
  11. That age gap is relevant to the plot. Angarano's character is kind of hopelessly in love with her character. Hopeless because of their age difference and also because LOOK AT HER FIANCE.

    ReplyDelete
  12. ah, good. Glad to hear it isn't a case of Hollywood going "What do you mean they aren't the same age? We told you they're both 25, what more do you want?".

    My friend's new girlfriend and I had to explain to our guy friends how attractive Lee Pace is this weekend. Apparently they don't see it, which clearly means they should be getting their vision checked.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Angel has recently confided in me that the level of my attraction to Lee Pace makes him feel inadequate. So I'm...this is me trying to dial it back. I'm failing so hard.

    ReplyDelete
  14. "And everything feels like the '70s, which is to say . . . kind of dirty?" ahahaha, yes. But at least they weren't the 80s, which is to say... a cultural black hole of terribleness and cocaine and money and NO.


    So... I don't have to read this because it's not that great, but I can if I want? Duly noted!

    ReplyDelete
  15. LEE PACE IS AMAZING there I said it. I'm just commenting on this because I want to go 'awwww' at the English/Australian thing. Because I'm pretty sure both times I went to America people were like 'Are you Australian?' NO, but please try again :)

    ReplyDelete
  16. Let's all group watch Pushing Daisies and sigh over how much we love Lee Pace. Because DAMN.


    I am so behind with all these comments but I don't even caaaaaare- LEE PACE FOREVER.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I know the DIFFERENCE, Laura. I just...it was a memory issue!

    ReplyDelete
  18. It's never too late to poke your head into the room and yell, LEE PACE FOREVER.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Heeeeey now, there were some good things created in the '80s. US, for one thing. And also...well there's something to be said for some of the music, anyway.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Ugh that Lee Pace gif is amazing *stares at it for another 20 minutes*

    I need to work up the courage to take this off the shelf and read it. I think Tom genuinely liked it, rather than just appreciating the art and concept and style...but he's weird and creepy like that.

    ReplyDelete